Choosing the right leader – Part deux
Last year I wrote a post on choosing the right leader that went through the criteria our staff uses to determine the drum major and guard captain of the ensemble. While that approach has always worked in the past, this year was a different story. Typically, we sit down as a staff immediately after all the drum majors and guard captain candidates try out and make the decision. But this year… oh, this year…
We had three well-qualified students – 1 junior and 2 seniors – who had demonstrated many or all of the traits we look for in a guard captain: Respect, skills, positive actions, and a good attitude and relationship with all. So how do you choose a captain when you’re in this predicament? I added something new to my list of criteria to consider.
My previous post concentrated mostly on the student’s past actions. So I needed to think more about the season ahead. More specifically, what I was expecting from the guard captain with this year’s group of students. In this case, here’s what I knew I wanted:
- A more disciplined group
- A captain who I felt could lead best by example (not only in terms of performance, but general attitude)
- A captain who I felt would use practice time most efficiently, taking advantage of those few precious blocks of time they get during all-band rehearsals.
Even with the added criteria, this was the hardest decision I’ve had to make in 8 seasons. All three candidates had the ability to help achieve these goals, but I chose the one that I believed would need the least molding (i.e. she was the most ready for the job). I look forward to working with her this coming season, and knowing that the remaining two will be (and always have been) incredible additions to the program.
How have you dealt with tough decisions like this in your program? Let me know…